'Never Events' are preventable medical errors resulting in serious consequences for patients, especially in surgery. (Representational Image: Pixabay) 
MedBound Blog

‘Never Events’ in Surgery Are a Growing Problem

Dr. Shreya Dave, MBBS

What Are 'Never Events'?

The term ‘never events’ was first coined in 2001 by the National Quality Forum (NQF), an important health organization of USA. The NQF promotes and ensures patient safety and healthcare quality through proper analysis and public reporting.

The NQF defines ‘never events’ as errors in medical care that are clearly identifiable, preventable, and serious in their consequences for patients. These indicate a real problem in the safety and credibility of a health care facility. These are called 'never events' because this should never have happened. These include retained foreign body, wrong site surgery, wrong patient surgery, and wrong procedure operations. Never events range from the wrong organ or side being operated on, the wrong prosthesis (such as hip joints) being inserted, to foreign objects (typically surgical instruments and swabs) being left inside the patient.

In the US, there has been a recent increase in never events, with 1,440 in 2022 and 1,411 in 2023. Before this, never events were fewer than 1,000 a year. In 2023, 18 percent of these events resulted in the patient dying and 8 percent in permanent harm or loss of function.

Recent Tragic Mishap

A 70-year-old man from Alabama recently died at a hospital in Florida when a surgeon mistakenly removed his liver instead of his spleen. The basics of anatomy are the first segment that are taught early in medicine. The liver is situated on the right side and the spleen is located on the left side, which is opposite to the liver. It is difficult to understand how a surgeon might confuse the spleen and liver, which is the foundation of undergraduate medical education. Most surgical careers with super specialty take at least 10 years of medical training to achieve in India, and similar lengths of time in the US and elsewhere. Despite these tedious years of education, the question on existence of never events still persists in the minds of most patients and their family.

The recent 'never event' occurred in Florida because the surgeon confused the liver and spleen.

Common Errors in Medicine

Each clinical department have areas where errors are more common than the rest of the field. Studies have tried to analyze and classify these errors over these years as the following:

  • Urology : Over 10 percent of cases fail to mention the diseased side (8.7 percent) or they mention the wrong side (3.3 percent).

  • Radiology: Wrongly placed radiological films could lead to patients having their healthy kidney removed rather than the diseased one.

  • Surgery: There have been cases where women's fertility have been affected because the surgeon removed the wrong fallopian tube or wrong side ovary during surgery.

  • Orthopaedics: This is one of the highest rates of wrong-site surgery. 21 percent of hand surgeons confirmed they'd operated on the wrong site.

Sometimes mistaken identities and clerical errors also result in death. Never events have huge implications for patients and their families, and many of them result in significant payouts. The cost of settled claims paid out by the NHS in 2015-20 was over £17 million. And, globally, between 1990 and 2010 claims were over US$1.3 billion (£990 million).

A shocking example occurred at a hospital in the Bronx, New York, where they turned off the life support of the wrong patient. In another tragic case, a 17-year-old girl died shortly after she was given a donor's heart and lungs, which were blood-group incompatible.

WHO's Surgical Safety Checklist

In 2008, the World Health Organization (WHO) launched the surgical safety checklist, which was adopted by the NHS in 2009. Similar protocols have been used in the US since 2004. These sorts of protocols bring consistency in the healthcare system. After the WHO's checklist was introduced, it was shown to reduce post-operative complications and deaths by 36 percent but the never events still have plenty of room for improvement.

WHO's Surgical Safety Checklist is divided into 3 segments as follows for a regular halt before proceeding further into surgery:

  • Before induction of anaesthesia

    - Has the patient confirmed his/her identity, site, procedure, and consent?

    - Is the site marked?

    -Is the anaesthesia machine and medication check complete?

    -Is the pulse oximeter on the patient and functioning?

    -Does the patient have a: Known allergy? Difficult airway or aspiration risk?

    -Risk of >500ml blood loss (7ml/kg in children)?

  • Before skin incision

    -Confirm all team members have introduced themselves by name and role.

    -Confirm the patient’s name, procedure, and where the incision will be made.

    -Has antibiotic prophylaxis been given within the last 60 minutes?

    -Anticipated Critical Events To Surgeon: What are the critical or non-routine steps? How long will the case take? What is the anticipated blood loss?

    -To Anaesthetist: Are there any patient-specific concerns?

    -To Nursing Team: Has sterility (including indicator results) been confirmed? Are there equipment issues or any concerns? Is essential imaging displayed?

  • Before patient leaves operating room

    -Nurse Verbally Confirms: The name of the procedure Completion of instrument, sponge and needle counts

    -Specimen labelling (read specimen labels aloud, including patient name)

    -Whether there are any equipment problems to be addressed

    -To Surgeon, Anaesthetist and Nurse: What are the key concerns for recovery and management of this patient?

'Never Events' are rarely published by the medical journals, probably due to the legal implications and the media tends to contain limited relevant medical information to create a real impact on the healthcare system. The purpose of this analysis is to create an awareness among surgeon’s fraternity and bring the attention of associations of surgeon bodies to this serious issue so that collective steps can be initiated to address it. In addition to the enforcing authorities, all other stake holders should wake up and must take collective and comprehensive approach to create a safety system inside the health care organizations. This topic reminds us of this famous quote by Emily Dickinson, C.1859:

"Surgeon’s must be very careful when they take the knife! Underneath their fine incisions stir the culprits – Life!”

Reference:

1) Kumar J, Raina R. 'Never Events in Surgery': Mere Error or an Avoidable Disaster. Indian J Surg. 2017 Jun;79(3):238-244. doi: 10.1007/s12262-017-1620-4. Epub 2017 Mar 28. PMID: 28659678; PMCID: PMC5473801.

2) Bowman CL, De Gorter R, Zaslow J, Fortier JH, Garber G. Identifying a list of healthcare 'never events' to effect system change: a systematic review and narrative synthesis. BMJ Open Qual. 2023 Jun;12(2):e002264. doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2023-002264. PMID: 37364940; PMCID: PMC10314656.

3) Conversation. (2024d, September 18). US Man Dies After Wrong Organ Removal – Surgical Errors Are A Growing Problem : ScienceAlert. ScienceAlert. https://www.sciencealert.com/us-man-dies-after-wrong-organ-removal-surgical-errors-are-a-growing-problem

By Dr. Shreya Dave

Juvenile Batten Disease Finds New Hope in RNA Therapeutic

Arkansas Sues YouTube Over Claims it's Fueling Mental Health Crisis

Three-Hour Blackout Shakes SAT Hospital, Probe Ordered By Health Minister

African Leaders at UN Warn Against Dwindling Malaria Funding

Snakebite Victim Dies After Police Detain Him for Hours Over Suspicion of Drinking in Bihar